Choose the product category before the panel
A facts-panel title follows the product’s category; it does not establish that category. Changing the title to Supplement Facts does not turn a conventional food into a dietary supplement.
FDA’s guidance on liquid products considers how a product is represented, including labeling, advertising, name, packaging, serving information, composition and directions for use. The guidance is particularly relevant when a beverage-like product is marketed as a supplement. A single design cue, bottle shape or ingredient is not a universal classification test.
Step 1: collect the representations
Gather the product name, statement of identity, intended use, directions, serving proposal, package design and marketing claims. Include website and marketplace descriptions when reviewing how the product is presented.
Step 2: confirm the category
Have the product owner resolve whether the item is a conventional food or dietary supplement under the applicable requirements. Review borderline products in their full context rather than relying on a three-question score or an automated classification label.
A gummy, powder or liquid can raise different questions depending on its actual formulation and representations. An example of one product does not classify all products in that form.
Step 3: prepare the appropriate source data
For conventional food, bring finished-product nutrition values, serving-basis information and relevant package details. For supplements, bring declared specifications, dietary-ingredient identities and forms, serving information and intended population.
Use the food data checklist to organize either workflow. A contaminant-only COA or a raw-ingredient report does not establish a complete finished-product panel.
Continue with the appropriate task
Start a Nutrition Facts draft or start a Supplement Facts draft after confirming your category. Review the output against the source and complete package requirements before use.
Import and screening tools assist preparation; they do not provide an FDA classification determination, approval or guaranteed marketplace acceptance.
Compare what each panel is built to describe
| Decision point | Nutrition Facts workflow | Supplement Facts workflow |
|---|---|---|
| Product context | Conventional food and beverage products | Products classified as dietary supplements |
| Core input | Finished-food nutrient amounts and serving basis | Dietary ingredient amounts, identities and serving basis |
| Other ingredients | Review the complete ingredient statement separately from nutrient quantities | Reconcile dietary ingredient rows with the Other Ingredients statement |
| Reference values | Apply the food rules for the intended population | Apply the supplement rules for the intended population and ingredient |
| Layout decision | Review serving size, RACC and applicable package/format conditions | Review the actual supplement format, comparison basis and population |
FDA's dietary supplement overview describes the product and labeling context. Neither a capsule picture nor a protein amount alone decides the legal classification.
Apply the three-step test to an actual brief
Step 1 — Establish the product's intended presentation. A conventional fruit drink and a supplement sold in liquid form can look similar. Ask how the product is represented and used; do not select a panel solely from the bottle shape or a supplier's generic template.
Step 2 — Request data for that product. For a food, collect the finished-product nutrient specification and serving/package facts. For a supplement, obtain the finished formula, dietary ingredient amounts, source forms and other ingredients. A heavy-metals COA for one raw material does not become either complete data set.
Step 3 — Inspect a matching output. Compare a granola-bar Nutrition Facts example with a daily-essentials Supplement Facts example. Look at the rows, serving declaration, units, references and ingredient information. The examples help you brief your manufacturer; their values are not recommended formulas.
What to do when the classification is uncertain
Keep the classification question open rather than exporting both panel types and choosing the one that looks more attractive. Ask the product owner or qualified reviewer to resolve the product's intended use and labeling context. Record that decision with the specification, then start the corresponding workflow.
Once the category is confirmed, use the Nutrition Facts engine or Supplement Facts engine. The same software can support both workflows without making their source requirements or display rules identical.
Sources
- FDA: distinguishing liquid supplements from beverages
- FDA Supplement Labeling Guide: general labeling
Sources and restored worked examples reviewed 8 November 2026.